How You Rate 2008-9
Now that the season is over, I thought I’d spend a Sunday afternoon summarising what the loyal band of raters has come up with this season. Luckily it is pretty much all the work I have to do as the system runs itself during the season.
As such it could support 100 or 300 adding their ratings just as easily as the 30 or so. Thus I’m appealing for a little help.
If you don’t currently contribute I’d be interested in why and whether there is anything that would change your mind.
If you do contribute I’d be keen to hear any ideas that would make it easier for you or for additional facilities you’d like to see.
afcw@foto.co.uk is the address to send any comments.
Individual Performances
First the ratings across the season, where Danny Kedwell is comfortably ahead of three centre halves led by Ben Judge. The top ten also contains a goalkeeper, a full back, another striker and three midfielders so a reasonable spread across the team.
Top Ten (minimum of 10 games)
| Name | Rating |
| Danny Kedwell |
7.24 |
| Ben Judge |
7.08 |
| Jason Goodliffe |
7.00 |
| Alan Inns |
6.95 |
| Jon Main |
6.83 |
| Luke Garrard |
6.80 |
| Tony Finn |
6.74 |
| Elliott Godfrey |
6.74 |
| Tom Davis |
6.69 |
| James Pullen |
6.65 |
The next table shows how often players have won man of the Match awards (individually or jointly) and the total number of votes for them over the season. Again Danny Kedwell is well ahead on both criteria but Kennedy Adjei appears from nowhere in the overall list into third in this category. Sam Hatton’s total of votes is a little suspect as he has a relative who comes on and votes for him in every match!
Man of the Match (minimum 3 Awards)
|
Name |
MotM |
Total Votes |
| Danny Kedwell |
12 |
162 |
| Alan Inns |
6 |
78 |
| Kennedy Adjei |
6 |
68 |
| Ben Judge |
5 |
81 |
| Jason Goodliffe |
4 |
56 |
| James Pullen |
4 |
49 |
| Sam Hatton |
3 |
93 |
| Tom Davis |
3 |
89 |
| Tony Finn |
3 |
77 |
| Jon Main |
3 |
57 |
| Chris Hussey |
3 |
30 |
The best performance in a single match was locked up by Jon Main in the very first game of the season with the top 5 places being monopolised by the two strikers.
Best Individual Performances
|
Player |
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
| Jon Main |
9/8/2008 |
A |
Newport County |
9.05 |
| Danny Kedwell |
18/10/2008 |
H |
Bishops Stortford |
8.68 |
| Danny Kedwell |
20/12/2008 |
H |
Newport County |
8.64 |
| Jon Main |
24/1/2009 |
H |
Braintree |
8.59 |
| Danny Kedwell |
21/10/2008 |
H |
Havant & Waterlooville |
8.58 |
Team Performances
The best team performance was judged as the dismantling of Braintree at Kingsmeadow, closely followed by the commanding home victory over Havant and Waterlooville.
Best Team Performances (Main Competitions)
|
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
|
24/1/2009 |
H |
Braintree Town |
8.20 |
|
21/10/2008 |
H |
Havant & Waterlooville |
8.19 |
|
31/1/2009 |
H |
Chelmsford City |
7.94 |
|
9/8/2008 |
A |
Newport County |
7.90 |
|
25/8/2008 |
H |
Bromley |
7.82 |
No great surprise that the worst team performance was the dismal display at Uxbridge, though with hindsight maybe it was the most important result of the season. The top 5 is rounded out by three of our league defeats and the dire goalless draw at St. Albans City.
Worst Team Performances (Main Competitions)
|
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
|
13/12/2008 |
A |
Uxbridge |
4.00 |
|
2/12/2008 |
H |
Eastleigh |
4.56 |
|
10/3/2009 |
A |
St. Albans City |
4.86 |
|
4/10/2008 |
A |
Worcester City (League) |
5.17 |
|
1/11/2008 |
A |
Chelmsford |
5.40 |
Opposition Performances
Little surprise that the best opposition performance was that of Wycombe Wanderers, the only team from a higher league that we faced. A Ryman Premier team sneaked into third place behind Welling’s excellent performance at Kingsmeadow. Good to see that neither Eastleigh nor Hampton made the top 5 although Bromley’s performance at Kingsmeadow, rather than Hayes Lane, did.
Best Opposition (Main Competitions)
|
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
|
13/12/2008 |
H |
Wycombe Wanderers |
7.52 |
|
2/12/2008 |
H |
Welling United |
7.00 |
|
11/10/2008 |
A |
Dover Athletic |
6.92 |
|
25/8/2008 |
H |
Bromley |
6.91 |
|
31/1/2009 |
H |
Chelmsford City |
6.74 |
A little hard on Fisher Athletic and Bognor Regis Town who both had reasons for fielding weak teams but the table doesn’t lie. Uxbridge were one of the worst teams but still good enough to beat us.
Worst Opposition (Main Competitions)
|
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
|
26/12/2008 |
A |
Fisher Athletic |
3.18 |
|
3/1/2009 |
A |
Bognor Regis Town |
4.14 |
|
18/10/2008 |
H |
Bishops Stortford |
4.18 |
|
20/12/2008 |
H |
Newport County |
4.48 |
|
13/12/2008 |
A |
Uxbridge |
4.50 |
Referees
Firstly thanks to Uncle Arthur and Paul Raymond for help in identifying referees. I can’t remember many of these performances which may reinforce the cliche about not noticing the good ones but Mr. Mason stands out for not falling for the usual Hampton tricks and his interesting approach to the treatment of injured players.
Best Referee
|
Player |
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
| T. Mason |
18/4/2009 |
A |
Hampton & Richmond Borough |
7.04 |
| L. Collins |
6/12/2008 |
A |
Team Bath |
6.83 |
| E. Smith |
25/8/2008 |
H |
Bromley |
6.68 |
| T. Hatt |
3/1/2009 |
A |
Bognor Regis Town |
6.29 |
| W.Atkin |
23/8/2008 |
A |
Basingstoke Town |
6.27 |
Mr. Knight heads the list of shame for his inability to handle drop balls and judge penalty appeals accurately.The referees for both Eastleigh games make up the numbers.
Worst Referee
|
Player |
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
| B. Knight |
7/3/2009 |
A |
Weston Super Mare |
3.00 |
| S. Knapp |
18/10/2008 |
H |
Bishops Stortford |
3.03 |
| C. Miller |
4/10/2008 |
H |
Worcester City (League) |
3.17 |
|
2/12/2008 |
H |
Eastleigh |
3.22 |
|
| S.Robbins |
28/3/2009 |
A |
Eastleigh |
3.46 |
A Trip Through History
The ratings system has now been running for three years so it is worth looking at this season in comparison to others. The first table looks at those who have achieved a rating of at least 7 across a season and Danny Kedwell has gone to the top of the tree with Ben Judge and Jason Goodliffe also joing the select role of honour.
Historic Ratings (minimum 7.00)
|
Season |
Name |
Rating |
|
2008 |
Danny Kedwell |
7.24 |
|
2006 |
Paul Lorraine |
7.20 |
|
2006 |
Roscoe Dsane |
7.09 |
|
2008 |
Ben Judge |
7.08 |
|
2007 |
Luis Cumbers |
7.07 |
|
2006 |
Luke Garrard |
7.03 |
|
2008 |
Jason Goodliffe |
7.00 |
Still nobody approaching Andy Little’s goalkeeping exploits at Aldershot but Jon Main’s hat-trick at Newport slots him into third place. A good reminder to see Luke Garrard featuring in both tables and we must hope he recovers to show his form in the Blue Square Premier.
Historic Individual Performances (minimum 9.00)
|
Player |
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
| Andy Little |
16/12/2006 |
A |
Aldershot |
9.39 |
| Steve Ferguson |
10/2/2007 |
H |
Bromley |
9.06 |
| Jon Main |
9/8/2008 |
A |
Newport County |
9.05 |
| Luke Garrard |
27/1/2007 |
H |
Harrow Borough |
9.00 |
Braintree and Havant come in as our best ever performances although I think maybe we underrated the Aldershot game at the time.
Historic Team Performances (minimum 8.00)
|
Date |
H/A |
Opposition |
Rating |
|
24/1/2009 |
H |
Braintree Town |
8.20 |
|
21/10/2008 |
H |
Havant & Waterlooville |
8.19 |
|
29/12/2007 |
A |
Staines |
8.17 |
|
16/12/2006 |
A |
Aldershot |
8.10 |
|
12/4/2008 |
A |
Ashford Town (Mddx) |
8.07 |
|
3/11/2007 |
H |
Chelmsford |
8.05 |
Source: ![]()






After a turgid display at St Albans where we couldn’t manage a shot on target during 90 minutes, Terry Brown has given us a timely shot in the arm by signing Kezie Ibe, who of course scored the winner for Ch£lmsford at Kingsmeadow last season after coming off the bench. Let’s hope he can perform similar feats for the Dons and help drag us out of the mini slump we find ourselves in. Wimbledon have enjoyed a certain tradition of effective black forwards in the past and whilst nobody would question the positions of Main and Kedwell, it’s great to have another option at this stage, which might just be enough to kick us out of the recent malaise. Looking at his recent goalscoring record, it hasn’t got near to the strike rate he achieved whilst at Staines but he could well prove to be the player for the big occasion, and we have eight big occasions remaining which all seem to have the “cup final” factor about them!